| [ KAIST ] in KIDS 글 쓴 이(By): homer (simpson) 날 짜 (Date): 2002년 11월 11일 월요일 오후 01시 08분 29초 제 목(Title): Re: 퀼리아? > [ KAIST ] in KIDS > 글 쓴 이(By): guest (123) <dialup22.cs.unc.> > 날 짜 (Date): 2002년 11월 8일 금요일 오후 05시 45분 29초 > 제 목(Title): Re: 퀼리아? > > > > IMO, the concept of 'pain' crucially depends on memory and survival. > > Why do we feel pain? Because it is bad for our survival. (If your > fingers are burnt, it's hard to catch animals or climb rocks. Less > chance of survival.) > > So, what is the role of pain? It is the most efficient mechanism to > force the body from danger. Once you burnt your finger to a glowing > red piece of charcoal, you don't try to pick it up again, however cute > it looks. Indeed, it is so strong that it defies curiosity, another > crucial feature of all the intelligent beings we know of! 다크맨님이 이미 비슷하게 설명하셨는데, 제가 약간 덧붙여 설명하겠습니다. 게스트님의 대답은 "우리는 왜 통증을 느끼는가?" 에 관한 것이고 이 질문에 대해서는 생존에 중대한 영향을 미치기 때문이라는 자명한 대답이 나옵니다. 하지만 우리가 궁금해 하는 문제는 그게 아니고 "우리가 통증을 느낄때 왜 하필 그런 느낌이 드는가?" 하는 겁니다. 게스트님이 설명하신대로라면 아무런 느낌을 느끼지 않고도 통증이라는 생존 메카니즘이 작동할 수 있어야합니다. > So, how can you make an AI feel pain? Easy, at least in (my) theory. > Give it a concrete form of existence, or something equivalent to it. > Define 'pain' as whatever that threats the form of existence. (If it > is powered by electricity, then put some acceleration sensor on the > battery.) Hard-wire the curcuit so that it should immediately respond > to the sensor signal, in such a way to reduce the signal ASAP. (It > doesn't have to be good --- it can learn later.) > > So, if you try to wrench away its battery, it will immediately run > from you --- or even bite you, if it has teeth. (Wow, that'd be cool.) > > Moreover, give it some memory, so that whenever a similar situation > arises, it will behave in order to minimize the chance of it ever being > caught in the same 'injury'. 그렇다면 갖난 아기처럼 아무런 경험이 없는 경우는 어떻게 되죠? 통증을 안 느끼나요? 갖난 아기들은 누가 바늘로 찔렀을때 어떻게 그게 "whatever that threats the form of existence"란걸 알까요? > Voila, you don't only give pain, you also give fear! Next time you > appear in the lab, it will run and hide beneath the desk, just like > a dog would if you had tried before to tear its heart away. > > Now it absolutely does not matter if it generates a human scream or > a human laughter as a side effect. You will merely think, "Wierd. > This machine screams like a laughing child!" > > After all, cats cry their love song in the voice of a starving baby, > so what's particularly wierd with a robot that laughs with pain? --- D'oh! |