| [ KAIST ] in KIDS 글 쓴 이(By): iLUSiON (화려한집념) 날 짜 (Date): 2003년 4월 2일 수요일 오전 09시 16분 38초 제 목(Title): Re: 레퍼리 리포트에서 some reviewers tend to be real nasty. if reviewers can not recognize any of coauthors or someone they basically hate, they will basically trash it from the beginning to end. if the papaper has not rejected, fix the problems and resubmit it. i know a guy who submitted to Nature and after about 6 revisions in 2 year period, finally got accepted. that paper is now one of the most widely quoted paper in some area. 20% reviewers = they hate everthing except waht they write. man... 50% reviwers = decent folks. 30% reviewers = incompetent morons. iLUSiON whitepolarcow@hotmail.com |